Connect with us

Brotherly Game Archive

You Be The GM: Should Conor Casey Stay Or Go?

How the Union’s Front Office makes personnel decisions is a murky mess, so we thought the fans could fill what appears to be a major void. Over the course of the MLS playoffs we’ll look at all of the Union’s key players and decide who should stay and who should go. Who do fans most want to see stay? Who do fans most want to see go? We’ll tally it all up before the MLS Expansion Draft.

Published

on

Conor Casey showed flashes of his brilliance this past campaign, and was a key reason behind the Union’s midseason run to respectability. He registered eight goals, good for second best behind Sebastian Le Toux. But as the season wore on, Casey’s minutes dwindled. Late in the season as a starter he was consistently subbed after 60 minutes. And as the tendinitis in his knee worsened, he stopped playing altogether. At age 33, Conor Casey can’t be depended on for more than depth at forward next season, leaving a huge vacancy that needs to be filled in the offseason.

Here are some facts and stats about Casey:

Conor Casey Whoscored.com Stats
Games Minutes Goals Assists Key Passes/Gm Pass % Tackles/Gm Int/Gm Clear/Gm Rating
2014 25 1459 8 1 0.8 65.7 0.2 0.2 0.7 6.73

Conor Casey does not have a contract with Philadelphia Union going into next season. Bringing Casey back next year would require a relatively big investment for a backup forward. Do his intangibles and experience bring enough to the Union to warrant a return to the Union? Would the Union want both Casey and Brian Brown as backups? Conor Casey has given two solid seasons to the Union, but does he have enough left in the tank?

Should the Union re-sign Conor Casey?

Previous You Be The GM votes:

Brian Brown

Maurice Edu

Amobi Okugo

author avatar
Jared Young

Copyright © 2026 Philadelphia Soccer Now

Be the First to Know When Philadelphia Soccer News Happens!

Sign-up now to get all of our stories sent directly to your inbox, as soon as they're published.

Thank you for subscribing.

Something went wrong.

Send this to a friend