Union fall flat in 1-0 loss to NYCFC

In a matchup that’s developed plenty of spice over recent seasons, the Union and NYCFC fell flat in this one – though NYCFC edged out a 1-0 victory. The match mirrored the weather: cold, wet, and far from pretty. Neither side looked particularly interested in competing under the grim April conditions.

Games at Citi Field and Yankee Stadium are usually high-paced due to the tighter field dimensions, but this one lacked the usual energy. Possession was split almost evenly, with NYCFC holding a slight edge at 51%, and that was evident just from watching the game. The ball spent much of the time in the air or skidding across the slick surface.

The Union, not typically a possession-heavy team, once again leaned into their direct style. They frequently looked to play long toward the heads of Bruno Damiani and Tai Baribo, but this approach was largely ineffective. The absence of now-former Union star Daniel Gazdag was clear – he was previously the link-up player who thrived on those knockdowns. Without him, the forwards lacked a presence to play off.

Despite their struggles in possession, the Union actually outshot NYCFC 16 to 11. However, the expected goals (xG) were almost identical: 1.27 for the Union and 1.26 for NYCFC.

The game’s decisive moment came ten minutes into the second half. Alonso Martínez capitalized on a stretched Union backline, chasing down a whipped ball from deep in NYCFC’s half. With a 2v2 situation unfolding, Union keeper Andrew Rick came out to close the angle but couldn’t stop the composed finish. The defense was left scrambling, and Martínez’s pace proved too much to handle.

After the goal, the Union made several substitutions in an attempt to swing momentum. One of their best chances came from a Chris Donovan header just inside the box. While well-placed, the header lacked the power needed to beat Matt Freese from that range.

Kai Wagner was easily the Union’s standout performer. Returning from injury, he looked like his old self – pushing forward on the left flank and delivering dangerous balls into the box. His set-piece delivery also caused problems, but despite a few late headed chances, the Union couldn’t find the equalizer.

Neither team was able to create much for themselves on the night, but NYCFC did just enough with Martínez’s goal. The result drops the Union to 4-1-3 on the season, though they still boast a +4 goal differential. That hot start to the season is starting to feel like a distant memory, especially with pivotal matchups ahead against Atlanta United, rivals D.C. United, and the unbeaten Columbus Crew.

With Gazdag’s departure, the Union now has more questions than answers – but their response will shape the direction of their season.